Blue Collar Aristocracy: Rethinking College, Trades, and the ROI of Education
This week's blogpost - https://bahnsen.co/45DhMjH
Host Blaine Carver and author Brett Bonecutter discuss Brett’s article “Blue Collar Aristocracy,” challenging the “college for everyone” assumption in education planning and default 529 saving. Drawing from Brett’s experience raising eight boys and shifts advisors see in client questions, they focus on the economics of college: high costs, average student debt over $40,000, negative ROI for the first decade after graduation, and a 52% underemployment rate that can lead to wage penalties and “scarring.” They distinguish unskilled factory work from skilled trades requiring training and licensing, argue that many degrees function as white-collar trade school, and highlight a paradoxical surge in demand for electricians and other trades driven by energy needs and data center growth amid an aging workforce and millions of projected unfilled trade jobs. They encourage parents and grandparents to match pathways to each child and consider apprenticeships and junior college.
00:00 Welcome and Guests
00:16 Why This Article
02:27 College Planning Shift
04:26 Mike Rowe and Rust Belt
07:48 Blue Collar Stigma
11:33 Skilled Trades Defined
14:01 Launching Into Adulthood
16:13 Debt and Fit
18:05 Saving Beyond 529s
21:06 Underemployment and ROI
25:24 College Value and Liberal Arts
31:49 Apprenticeship and Demand
35:15 Trade Labor Shortage
37:13 Blue Collar Success Stories
40:17 Wrap Up and Next Episode
Links mentioned in this episode:
Get new episodes of Thoughts On Money [TOM] automatically